Ebook The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner
So, when you need quickly that book The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner, it does not should get ready for some days to obtain guide The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner You can directly get the book to conserve in your device. Even you enjoy reading this The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner everywhere you have time, you could enjoy it to check out The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner It is definitely useful for you who want to obtain the more valuable time for reading. Why do not you spend five minutes as well as invest little cash to obtain the book The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner right here? Never let the extra thing quits you.
The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner
Ebook The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner
The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner. Let's read! We will usually learn this sentence all over. When still being a children, mama made use of to order us to always review, so did the educator. Some books The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner are completely reviewed in a week as well as we require the responsibility to assist reading The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner Just what around now? Do you still enjoy reading? Is checking out just for you that have commitment? Not! We right here supply you a new book qualified The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner to check out.
By reviewing The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner, you can know the understanding as well as things more, not only concerning exactly what you get from people to people. Schedule The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner will be more trusted. As this The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner, it will actually give you the good idea to be successful. It is not just for you to be success in specific life; you can be successful in everything. The success can be started by understanding the standard knowledge as well as do activities.
From the mix of knowledge and also actions, an individual can boost their ability and also capacity. It will certainly lead them to live as well as work far better. This is why, the pupils, workers, and even employers must have reading practice for publications. Any book The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner will provide particular understanding to take all perks. This is exactly what this The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner informs you. It will add more expertise of you to life and also function better. The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner, Try it as well as prove it.
Based upon some encounters of many people, it remains in reality that reading this The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner could help them making better selection and provide even more experience. If you intend to be among them, allow's acquisition this publication The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner by downloading and install guide on web link download in this website. You could get the soft data of this publication The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner to download as well as put aside in your readily available electronic tools. What are you awaiting? Let get this publication The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner on-line and review them in any time and any sort of place you will certainly read. It will certainly not encumber you to bring heavy book The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning Of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), By Ernest Gellner inside of your bag.
How did psychoanalysis become so accepted by the public? This provocative book reconstructs the system of ideas upon which the theory and practice of psychoanalysis rests, describing a modern culture that has created a psychic or a spiritual void that psychoanalysis seems custom-made to fill. Gellner approaches the question as a sociologist and attains a broad perspective on the ideas of the psychoanalytic movement as a system of cultural beliefs.
- Sales Rank: #2275286 in Books
- Published on: 1996-08-12
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.00" h x .70" w x 6.00" l, .93 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 241 pages
Review
‘The Psychoanalytic Movement was recognized as a classic upon its publication. José Brunner's new introduction places the argument within the context of “the Freud wars”, making it clear that the book was as concerned to explain the fabulous success of psychoanalysis as to debunk its pretensions. This may be Gellner's greatest book, containing as it does a general view of the history of philosophy and the character of modernity.’ John A. Hall, McGill University
Previous praise for The Psychoanalytic Movement:
‘A marvel… This is a brilliantly written book, every page sparkling with intelligence, style and substance. Gellner provides a welcome and literate overview of the latest philosophic controversy about the logical status of psychoanalytic propositions. Its every page instructs and enlivens and represents a tribute to humane intelligence.’ New Statesman
‘In a stylish, witty and deceptively readable book, Gellner exposes the secular religious nature of the psychoanalytic enterprise. He admits that a compelling, charismatic belief must possess more than merely the promise of succour in a plague and links with the background convictions of the age.’ Nature
‘This is the first determined effort to account for a very odd historical and sociological phenomenon in realistic and meaningful terms…and it makes very good sense. Gellner is incisive, agreeable to read and often witty.’ Institute of Psychiatry Journal
From the Back Cover
How did the language of psychoanalysis become the dominant idiom in which the middle classes of the industrialized West speak about their emotions? Ernest Gellner offers a forceful and complex answer to this intriguing question in The Psychoanalytic Movement. This landmark study argues that although psychoanalysis offers an incisive picture of human nature, it provides untestable operational definitions and makes unsubstantiated claims concerning its therapeutic efficacy. In a new foreword José Brunner expands on the central argument of The Psychoanalytic Movement. Placing Gellner's work in the context of contemporary hostile critiques of Freud, Brunner argues that these two blatantly different thinkers might also be seen as kindred spirits.
About the Author
His first book, Words and Things (1958) prompted a leader in The Times and a month-long correspondence on its letters page over his attack on linguistic philosophy. As the Professor of Philosophy, Logic and Scientific Method at the London School of Economics for 22 years, the William Wyse Professor of Social Anthropology at the University of Cambridge for eight, and finally as head of the new Centre for the Study of Nationalism in Prague, Gellner fought all his life—in his writing, his teaching, and through his political activism—against what he saw as closed systems of thought, particularly communism, psychoanalysis, relativism, and the dictatorship of the free market.
Most helpful customer reviews
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful.
A Necessary Book
By Gypsy Samuels
Gellner was born in Paris in 1925, and was educated in Prague and England. Among other positions he held, he was professor of philosophy and sociology at the London School of Economics from 1949 to 1984. This kind of background is very important to understanding and questioning Freud's basic ideas. Most of the beginning texts books on "Western Psychology" today talk about Freud as if he was the father of the "unconscious" and an original genius who "discovered" and created, almost single-handily, the beginnings of what we know today as the "Science of Psychology."
This myth is perpetuated hundreds of times over in both college text books and, especially, in the media. Well, Gellner lived all during the time that Freud was creating his own mythology and writing about successful therapeutic encounters with patients that never happened, or at least should be questioned as driven by a man who was a creator of his own novel. Freud reeks of subjectivity and a mania to be someone who was only one of the players of the time.
That Gellner was trained in philosophy and sociology is very important to understanding Freud. Gellner is not repeating the standard story about Freud because he had no interest or involvement in the American text book industry or American academic world of book publishing, among other realities. As I noticed immediately, he was only interested in investigating the main ideas behind the psychoanalytic movement as any good philosopher does--just for themselves and in the context of the idea's life. This book is not a "great read" or in any way targeted to the incoming freshman of American universities. Gellner digs, questions, and relentlessly questions the basic ideas of the psychoanalytic movement. So, if you think that "everyone knows" that we all have "unconscious" minds or areas of thought, reason and many, many buried past events that drive our present interactions and emotions and human possibilities that must be revealed in order for us to be successful, happy or capable of achieving our goals in life--then do not read this book! You start to find out that Freud lived in a rather bloody moment in history and needed money to feed his family and created a novel to make all that happen. You will not find all of that in Gellner's book. But, you will find "...what Freud in effect did was to supplement and fortify a naïve mentalist model of conscious human behavior, by endowing the conscious mind with a kind of strange doppelganger who, however, all in all, rather resembled his partner." (p.86) Where is that criticism in Psychology 101? And, of course, in all the following notations of Freud being the person who "discovered the unconscious." Or, maybe he "created it?" After all, no one in the history of ideas, philosophy, meditation, spiritual quests or other self human examination processes, in any time before Freud, questioned how the mind works in any form of a "scientific" examination as objective as Freud--right? Good Hunting.
22 of 27 people found the following review helpful.
The future of an illusion
By David H Miller
In this book, Ernest Gellner uses the psychoanalytic movement as a "case study" to explore the general human tendency to create delusional ideological systems which serve various political, social, and psychological needs. He also focuses in on the specific structural features of modern life that made psychoanalysis an especially successful ideology.
As Gellner sums up in his final chapter, "In a sense, the present book is more interested in our Zeitgeist than in psychoanalysis. The crucial strategic position occupied by Freudianism in the social and intellectual history of mankind, makes it possible for us to learn a vast amount from it about, on the one hand, the general anatomy of belief systems and, on the other, the special conditions prevalent in our age."
In his first two chapters, Gellner focuses in on what might be called the modern predicament. Before the rise of natural science and philosophical empiricism, it was easy to explain the mixture of good and evil, the sheer perversity, embodied in human beings. Humans were, quite literally, halfway between beasts and angels.
The rise of science and modern philosophy invalidated that belief. Taking David Hume as a prime example, Gellner shows that the scientific, empiricist thought of the Enlightenment abandoned the angel/beast dichotomy. The Enlightenment theorists naturalized man: the model of man they ended up with, which Gellner dubs the "Bundleman," was a random mixture of self-interested desires and needs which were easily satisfied by a conservatively cautious policy of maximizing pleasure and minimizing pain.
Real human beings, of course, act much more like a mixture of angel and beast than the cautiously and rationally selfish "Bundleman" of the Enlightenment.
Nietzsche was, Gellner claims, the first serious post-Enlightenment thinker to fully realize this fact, and the realization finally drove poor Nietzsche insane.
Freud's genius was to take the Nietzschean insight and domesticate it, thereby turning it into the basis of a very successful, very lucrative pseudo-scientific cult - psychoanalysis.
Freud's task was made easier by certain features of the modern world. The modern world exhibits deep reverence for applied science, especially medicine. In modern industrial societies, technology has eradicated most traditional physical threats (starvation, plague, wild animals, etc.). In our society, the pressing threats perceived by most people lie rather in the increasing complexity of, and importance placed upon, human relationships. It is just in this area of interpersonal relationships where psychoanalysis offered help.
Most of the book explores the tricks and turns by which psychoanalysis maintained its authority. Nowadays, now that there is hardly an intelligent person left who is a hard-core believer in the Freudian faith, is this of any more than historical interest?
Yes.
While Freud may finally be buried, his residue endures -- as "therapy," "couselling," "adjustment," etc. -- and continues to muddle our thinking process and our ability to make moral evaluations. As Gellner rhetorically asks, concerning the Holy Grail of "adjustment," "[I]s adaptation, adjustment to any regime, including a tyrannical one, a sign of mental health?" The Soviets, hardly orthodox Freudians, famously answered "Yes!"
But even more important, as Gellner emphasizes, the fraud of Freudianism is a typical example of the functioning of human society in general:
"Societies possess techniques for rendering ideas socially constitutive, and these techniques tend to share certain formal features. It is important to remember that this is the normal condition of mankind: most ideas of most men at most times are beyond the reach of questioning... An idea does not have simply a cognitive role...it is at the same time linked to a set of personal relations, to loyalties, hierarchies, sentiments, hopes and fears. To shake the idea would be to disturb all that. Most men are neither willing nor able to do that."
To put it more bluntly, the structure of all hitherto existing human societies is grounded in socially-imposed, emotionally-compelling lies.
Did Freud and his colleagues engage in bizarre intellectual contortions to prevent their ideas from being questioned or subjected to criticism?
Yes... but have you ever asked a liberal why we must slavishly accede to the results of a democratic election? The answer is that if you choose to vote, you are obliged to accept the results, and, if you don't vote, you have no right to complain. Is Freudian reasoning any more circular than that?
Did Freud and his colleagues frantically avoid confronting their theories with empirical reality? (Freud once declared that "I cannot advise too strongly against" seeking out empirical evidence to check the conclusions of a psychoanalytic diagnosis because the result would be that "confidence in the analysis is shattered and a court of appeal is set up over it.")
Yes... but have you ever talked with a conservative about the actual historical process by which the US Constitution was "ratified"?
Do Freudians apply different standards to themselves than to all other human beings, accusing critics and skeptics of being mentally and morally deranged?
Yes... but have you ever tried asking a Christian why, since they preach that Jesus taught the pacifist doctrines of "Resist not evil!" and "Turn the other cheek!", many Christians are among the most violent and militaristic people on the planet?
What then would happen if everyone learned the central lesson of Gellner's book -- that deception, dishonesty, and manipulation are at the heart not only of the psychoanalytic movement but of nearly all forms of social authority?
If people simply cease believing in authority, them, like Tinkerbell, authority simply dies.
If the world were free of lies, deception, and manipulation, then the authority of clergymen and governments, of judges, schoolteachers, psychotherapists, professors, and policemen, would all simply disappear.
Garbagemen can still collect garbage, farmers can still farm, and deliverymen can still deliver even if no one "believes' in them. But if no one believes in clergymen, or psychoanalysts, or Presidents, then there would no longer be clergymen, psychoanalysts, or Presidents. Like Tinkerbell, they would simply fade away.
And, perhaps, that would be a very good thing indeed.
11 of 15 people found the following review helpful.
UNATO
By Luc REYNAERT
Ernest Gellner stigmatizes Freudianism as a secular religion, where the Unconscious (a new version of the Original Sin) is treated as a Revelation, with a sharp distinction between the sacred (those under analysis) and the profane, between the good (the true believers) and the bad, and where reason must be suspended.
Freud's concepts are untestable (the experience - transfer - between analysand and analyst is unique) and nebulous (reality can always be made conform to the system).
His basic technique is free association which should lead to the uncovering of repressed mental contents and correspondent therapeutic consequences for the patient.
The only testable component of the theory are its therapeutic claims, but the effectiveness of the therapy is extremely dubious and unproven.
For the author, Freudianism is a self-perpetuating, falsification-evading, closed system, which controls its own database. In one word, it is a pseudo-science.
Its enormous vested interests (also financial) are cultivated and protected by a guild: UNATO (United Nations Analysis and Therapy Organization).
This brilliantly written, corrosive text contains excellent short evaluations of Nietzsche, Marx, Berkeley, Plato and Stoicism.
A must read for all guild-members and outsiders.
See all 3 customer reviews...
The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner PDF
The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner EPub
The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner Doc
The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner iBooks
The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner rtf
The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner Mobipocket
The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner Kindle
!! Ebook The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner Doc
!! Ebook The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner Doc
!! Ebook The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner Doc
!! Ebook The Psychoanalytic Movement: The Cunning of Unreason (Rethinking Theory), by Ernest Gellner Doc
