PDF Ebook Reduction and Givenness: Investigations of Husserl, Heidegger, and Phenomenology (Studies in Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy (Pape
Yet below, we will show you incredible point to be able constantly review the e-book Reduction And Givenness: Investigations Of Husserl, Heidegger, And Phenomenology (Studies In Phenomenology And Existential Philosophy (Pape anywhere and whenever you take area and also time. Guide Reduction And Givenness: Investigations Of Husserl, Heidegger, And Phenomenology (Studies In Phenomenology And Existential Philosophy (Pape by just can assist you to realize having guide to read every time. It won't obligate you to consistently bring the thick book any place you go. You can simply keep them on the gizmo or on soft data in your computer system to consistently review the space during that time.
Reduction and Givenness: Investigations of Husserl, Heidegger, and Phenomenology (Studies in Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy (Pape
PDF Ebook Reduction and Givenness: Investigations of Husserl, Heidegger, and Phenomenology (Studies in Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy (Pape
Reduction And Givenness: Investigations Of Husserl, Heidegger, And Phenomenology (Studies In Phenomenology And Existential Philosophy (Pape. In undertaking this life, numerous people consistently attempt to do and obtain the ideal. New understanding, experience, session, and also everything that can boost the life will certainly be done. However, several individuals often really feel perplexed to get those things. Feeling the restricted of encounter and sources to be far better is one of the does not have to have. However, there is an extremely easy thing that could be done. This is what your instructor always manoeuvres you to do this one. Yeah, reading is the response. Reviewing a publication as this Reduction And Givenness: Investigations Of Husserl, Heidegger, And Phenomenology (Studies In Phenomenology And Existential Philosophy (Pape as well as various other referrals could enhance your life quality. How can it be?
This is why we recommend you to consistently see this page when you require such book Reduction And Givenness: Investigations Of Husserl, Heidegger, And Phenomenology (Studies In Phenomenology And Existential Philosophy (Pape, every book. By online, you might not getting guide establishment in your city. By this on-line library, you could locate the book that you truly want to review after for long time. This Reduction And Givenness: Investigations Of Husserl, Heidegger, And Phenomenology (Studies In Phenomenology And Existential Philosophy (Pape, as one of the recommended readings, tends to remain in soft documents, as all of book collections here. So, you may additionally not wait for few days later on to receive as well as read guide Reduction And Givenness: Investigations Of Husserl, Heidegger, And Phenomenology (Studies In Phenomenology And Existential Philosophy (Pape.
The soft data suggests that you need to go to the link for downloading and afterwards save Reduction And Givenness: Investigations Of Husserl, Heidegger, And Phenomenology (Studies In Phenomenology And Existential Philosophy (Pape You have actually owned the book to check out, you have posed this Reduction And Givenness: Investigations Of Husserl, Heidegger, And Phenomenology (Studies In Phenomenology And Existential Philosophy (Pape It is simple as visiting the book establishments, is it? After getting this brief description, hopefully you can download and install one and also start to review Reduction And Givenness: Investigations Of Husserl, Heidegger, And Phenomenology (Studies In Phenomenology And Existential Philosophy (Pape This book is very simple to read whenever you have the downtime.
It's no any type of mistakes when others with their phone on their hand, as well as you're also. The distinction could last on the material to open up Reduction And Givenness: Investigations Of Husserl, Heidegger, And Phenomenology (Studies In Phenomenology And Existential Philosophy (Pape When others open the phone for talking and speaking all points, you could occasionally open up as well as check out the soft file of the Reduction And Givenness: Investigations Of Husserl, Heidegger, And Phenomenology (Studies In Phenomenology And Existential Philosophy (Pape Certainly, it's unless your phone is available. You could likewise make or save it in your laptop computer or computer system that reduces you to review Reduction And Givenness: Investigations Of Husserl, Heidegger, And Phenomenology (Studies In Phenomenology And Existential Philosophy (Pape.
Through careful analysis of phenomenological texts by Husserl and Heidegger, Marion argues for the necessity of a third phenomenological reduction that concerns what is fully implied but left largely unthought by the phenomenologies of both Husserl and Heidegger: the unconditional "givenness" of the phenomenon. At once historically grounded and radically new, this phenomenology of givenness has revitalized phenomenological debate in Europe and the U.S.
- Sales Rank: #1026185 in Books
- Brand: Brand: Northwestern University Press
- Published on: 1998-05-13
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.00" h x 1.00" w x 6.00" l, .87 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 261 pages
- Used Book in Good Condition
Language Notes
Text: English (translation)
Original Language: French
About the Author
Jean-Luc Marion (born 3 July 1946) is a postmodern philosopher and a former student of Jacques Derrida. Marion's take on the postmodern is informed by patristic and mystical theology, phenomenology, and modern philosophy. Although much of his academic work has dealt with Descartes and phenomenologists like Martin Heidegger and Edmund Husserl, it is rather his explicitly religious works that have garnered much recent attention.
Most helpful customer reviews
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful.
A New Configuration
By Michael H. Shenkman
This is a difficult book. I could have marked it down for that; but aren't philosophically curious people prepared for difficulty, for having their complacency in conveniently arrayed categories disrupted? Maybe not, for some; but they are semantic manipulators, and this book is not for them.
This is a philosophical "argument" the way that "Moby Dick" is a story about whaling. Philosophy here is a field onto which we are ushered so as to be cut adrift, freed from subjective and objective lock down. Clinging to this framework, as did Husserl, as did Heidegger, at a different level, is to be entangled in one's own ropes, bobbing, weaving and succumbing to a deeper and unfathomable depth.
Hegel's "Phenomenology of Spirit" took us through the permutations of the formation of Reason such that subjects and objects can lay claim to certainty; Marion's phenomenology takes us from there, through Hegelian negation (in the form of ontic boredom) or Nietzschean nihilism, right to that milieu where we choose to swim (stand, such as we can) or strap ourselves to the great white apparition (Plato's light, illuminating phenomena, but in which nothing is seen).
This is a book that is out of reach of neo-Kantians (see Dominique Janicaud's flailing at Marion in his essay in "Phenomenology and the 'Theological Turn'"), and both positivists and pragmatists would be at a loss. How can there even be a notion of a "claim" or a "call" to which we must respond that is prior to our existence as a subject? Hint: think being born!!! I think Heidegger would be pleased that the crushing limitations of his thinking, confined in a construction of a grand, but nihilating notion, have been respectfully, appreciatively and totally appropriately surpassed. This is not a critique of Heidegger or Husserl, but an earnest, honest, indeed, worthy continuation of the freely constituting potencies they pointed to, and even longed for, and single-mindedly pursued.
The work leads up to a startling and striking means of phenomenological explication, in four concise steps, that may provide a method for a new mode of discourse. Marion exemplifies that discourse here. His other "phenomenological works," "Being and Givenness" and "In Excess" lay out how the call takes on shapes of Event, Idol, Icon and Flesh, and eventually and ultimately, the Call and Revelation, each of which lays out a post-Hegelian phenomenology in which we must respond by "Hearing" or non-visually discerning that which always already has surpassed our grasping for presence (or nihilating superiority). These are not existential "complexes" that are analyzed according to given schema, but are contexts of realization that set categories and the very ability to analyze at all, into motion (Event: Quantity; Idol:Quality; Flesh: Relation; icon: modality). I could quibble, and will someday, with this transit from moment to category, but that is not the point here, or in this book. Instead, here a powerful, strong, vitally gripping presentation of primal givenness at the moment of singular emergence is offered -- a vision not yet even contemplated in self-organization studies, but now given the leeway to do so -- that can begin the real transformation of the human endeavor. Now we can set sail, as Nietzsche longed to do (but could not while remaining in his current terrestrial bondage).
This is a work, indeed part of a great "corpus," a body of work, that bears promise, not of comprehension and appropriation, but of a continuing voyage: in wonder, never abated; in openness,, never conquered; and in generativity, never named or appropriated.
Are you ready to set sail? Are you ready to encounter, not the sirens, or the Great White Whale, but, as Heidegger calls it, "the cheerfulness and gentleness of creative longing"? ("What is Metaphysics" in "Pathways," p. 93.), where you will encounter, neither certainties nor sirens, but "new and rigorous paradoxes"? (Marion, R&G, p. 205)
10 of 22 people found the following review helpful.
Givenness of the Given
By Sebastian Luft
Jean-Luc Marions fast schon berühmt zu nennende Studie über "Reduction and Givenness", im französischen Original in 1989 veröffentlicht (Originaltitel: "Réduction et Donation") liegt nun in englischer Übersetzung vor. Das Buch war wohl v.a. deshalb insbesondere in der französischen phänomenologischen Szene so einflußreich, weil es seinem Autor gelang, auf originelle Weise verschiedene, vieldiskutierte philosophische Stränge (Husserl, Heidegger, Levinas, M. Henry) zu einer umfassend neuen Darstellung von "Reduktion", hier verstanden als das Grundverfahren der Phänomenologie schlechthin, zusammenzufassen und sich damit einen eigenen Standpunkt in aktuellen Auseinandersetzungen u.a. mit Derrida zu erarbeiten. "Reduktion" wird hier in erster Linie als reine Methodik begriffen, deren sich die Phänomenologie - genauer jede philosophische Bemühung, die sich phänomenologisch nennt -, bedient, ja bedienen muß. Umfassend ist Marions Darstellung in diesem Licht v.a. deshalb, weil er eine allgemeine Deutung der Reduktion vorlegt, die, so die These, von der Anfangsgestalt bei Husserl ihre immer radikaleren Schichten enthüllt und so in Konsequenz zu dem kommt, was Marion "reine Gegebenheit" (donation, givenness) nennt. Hierbei ist die Reduktion weniger als operativer Methodenschritt thematisch, sondern vielmehr die Weise, wie radikal und worauf die Reduktion reduziert. Wird selbige erstmals bei Husserl "entdeckt" und angewendet, so versucht Marion nachzuweisen, daß sie dort zwar eine, über die natürliche Einstellung hinausgehende, Radikalität besitzt, aber doch nicht radikal genug vorgeht: Mit der Reduktion auf die weltkonstituierende transzendentale Subjektivität bleibt Husserl im modernen reflexionstheoretischen Paradigma und dem Subjekt-Objekt-Dualismus befangen und setzt ein allzu rigides Verständnis der Phänomenologie als bloßer Wirklichkeit (anstatt, wie Heidegger, als Möglichkeit) voraus.
Radikaler dagegen ist bereits Heidegger, der genau diese Voraussetzungshaftigeit der Husserlschen Phänomenologie kritisiert und dagegen auf das reine Sein, das nicht mehr Sein von Seiendem ist, reduziert (!). Damit wird vorausgesetzt, daß es auch bei Heidegger so etwas wie eine Reduktion gibt. Oder anders gesagt: Marion unterstellt ein Verständnis von Reduktion (ein sehr allgemeines, notwendigerweise), das es ermöglicht, auch Heideggers Verfahren als Reduktion bezeichnen zu können. Der Leser vermißt leider eine methodologische Reflexion, die - bei Heidegger, wie beim Folgenden - die Möglichkeit einer solchen Lesart von Reduktion begründet oder zumindest diskutiert. Der Begriff "Reduktion" bleibt leider "operativ verschattet", statt daß er - dem Titel des Buches nach eigentlich erwartungsgemäß - ins Thema rückt.(1)
Wie der Titel bereits programmatisch verheißt, wird auch die Heideggersche Reduktion kritisiert mit dem Nachweis, daß auch sie nicht radikal genug sei; denn das Heideggersche Sein, das sich gibt und dem Menschen in einem Seinsgeschick offenbart, setzt wiederum voraus, daß es sich gibt, supponiert das pure Daß, oder mit Marion, seine Gabe selbst. Sein setzt seine Gebung voraus, und auf die Frage, was die Gabe denn gibt, so wird geantwortet: sich selbst. Die Gabe gibt nichts anderes als sich selbst. Wenn das keine Tautologie sein soll, muß sich dies näher bestimmen lassen. Marion meint hiermit offensichtlich eine reine Gegebenheit, die noch jenseits aller Gegensätze (subjektiv-objektiv, aktiv-passiv, Sein-Nichts) angesiedelt ist und eine Art radikaler Ur-Passivität (offensichtlich nicht mehr als in der Opposition von aktiv-passiv) darstellt, hinter die nun wirklich nicht mehr zurückzugehen ist. Dieser Schritt ist sicherlich von Michel Henrys radikalem Rückgang (in diesem Sinn vergleichbar mit einer Reduktion, zumindest in der Lesart Rolf Kühns) auf die absolute Passivität inspiriert, wenn auch Marion sicherlich diese direkte Identifikation ablehnen würde.
Die kritische Frage wäre dann, was über dieses "Phänomen", das eigentlich jenseits aller Phänomenalität angesiedelt ist, noch ausgesagt werden kann im Rahmen von Phänomenologie, die doch das Paradigma von Evidenz und Zur-Anschauung-Bringen nicht aufgeben kann, ohne sich selbst dabei aufzugeben. Die Radikalität der radikalsten aller Reduktionen müßte zur Konsequenz haben, sich nicht mehr als phänomenologisch bezeichnen zu dürfen. Doch die Grenzen und Konsequenzen dieses Vorgehens können auch nicht mehr phänomenologisch reflektiert werden. Diese Undeutlichkeit läßt es zuletzt fraglich oder zumindest unklar erscheinen, worin sich Marions philosophischer Versuch noch als phänomenologisch rechtfertigen läßt. Nicht, daß "die Phänomenologie" über alles ginge, aber was ist es, womit Marion über die Phänomenologie (hinaus)geht?
Dieser Kritik ungeachtet, ist "Réduction et Donation" ein beeindruckendes, gelehrtes und v.a. einflußreiches Buch, das man gelesen haben muß, um von sich behaupten zu können, etwas von französischer Gegenwartsphilosophie zu verstehen. Daher ist es höchst verdienstvoll, daß dieses Werk nun auch in englischer Sprache verfügbar ist, was ihm so evtl. sogar zu einer Wiedergeburt verhelfen wird. Die Übersetzung ist hierbei als gelungen - elegant und technisch-präzise zugleich - zu bezeichnen, und Northwestern hat sie auch zu einem vernünftigen Preis im Verlagsprogramm. Angesichts des Interesses an französischer Philosophie in amerikanischen kontinentalphilosophischen Kreisen hat Northwestern sicherlich klug daran getan, gerade dieses Buch aufzunehmen, sofern es eine ganze Diskussionslage in ihrer Breite auf kompaktem Raum (261 S.) bündelt.
Sebastian Luft (Leuven)
(1) Rudolf Bernet hat - m.E. sehr plausibel - den Versuch unternommen, den Reduktionsbegriff auf eine solche Weise zu verallgemeinern, um sie mit der Idee der Phänomenologie selbst, unter Absehen von einem bestimmten Denker, in Einklang zu bringen; vgl. seinen Text: "Phenomenological Reduction and the Double Life of the Subject", in: Reading Heidegger from the Start. Essays in His Earliest Thought, ed. by Theodore Kisiel and John van Buren, State University of New York 1994, S. 245-267.
Reduction and Givenness: Investigations of Husserl, Heidegger, and Phenomenology (Studies in Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy (Pape PDF
Reduction and Givenness: Investigations of Husserl, Heidegger, and Phenomenology (Studies in Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy (Pape EPub
Reduction and Givenness: Investigations of Husserl, Heidegger, and Phenomenology (Studies in Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy (Pape Doc
Reduction and Givenness: Investigations of Husserl, Heidegger, and Phenomenology (Studies in Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy (Pape iBooks
Reduction and Givenness: Investigations of Husserl, Heidegger, and Phenomenology (Studies in Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy (Pape rtf
Reduction and Givenness: Investigations of Husserl, Heidegger, and Phenomenology (Studies in Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy (Pape Mobipocket
Reduction and Givenness: Investigations of Husserl, Heidegger, and Phenomenology (Studies in Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy (Pape Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar